PUNISHMENT FOR GREED IN PROSE NARRATIVES ABOUT HIDDEN TREASURES

Скачать pdf
Альманах
Key words
greed, punishment, treasure, bylicka (memorate), belief legend
Author
NATALIYA KOTEL’NIKOVA
About the Author
NATALIYA KOTEL’NIKOVA
E-mail: tusjakot@yandex.ru
Tel.: +7 (499) 246-65-01
6, Turchaninov side-str., Moscow,119034, Russian Federation
PhD (Philology), Vice Editor-in-chief of “Traditional Culture” — the Scholarly Almanac, State Republican Center of Russian Folklore of the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation

Body

This paper deals with the motif of punishment for greed and avarice, which appears widely in various genres of folklore. It is exemplified in motif’s functioning in prose belief narratives about hidden treasures, primarily. This motif of trial the character gets to go through and his punishment is actualized in these narratives due to the core component of the meaning of treasures in East Slavic folklore, namely that the treasure was believed to appear as a sort of diabolic temptation. Different types of stories, that represent the punishment motif, are identified as memorates, fabulates and belief legends, that are opposed to fairy tales as oral prose genre in Russian folklore scholarship. Motif representation removes the range of genre features of the given text from the “bylichka” (memorate) genre with its 1st person mode of narration, that indicates stories about wonderful treasures, to the border of the legendary and even fabulous prose.

References

Aristov N. Ya. (1867) Predaniya o kladakh [Legends about Hidden Treasures]. Zapiski RGO po otdeleniyu etnografii [Notes of the Russian Geographical Society, the Department of Ethnography].Vol. 1. St. Petersburg. In Russian.


Biryukov V. P. (comp.) (1936) Dorevolyutsionnyy fol’klor na Urale [Pre-revolutionary Folklore in the Urals]. Sverdlovsk. In Russian.

Boganeva A. M. (comp.) (2013) Tradycyjnaja mastackaja kul,tura belarusaw [Traditional Art Culture of Belarusians]. In 2 vol. Vol. 2. Concept and General Ed. by T. B. Varfolomeeva. Minsk. In Belarusian.

Bogdanov K. A. (1995) Den’gi v fol’klore [Money in the Folklore]. St. Petersburg. In Russian.

Bogdanovich A. M. (1995) Perezhitki drevnego mirosozertsaniya u belorusov [The Remnants of the Ancient World-view among Belarusians]. [Grodno, 1895]. Minsk. In Russian.

Chernykh A. V. (2012) Komara — khozyayka zolota i khranitel’nitsa kladov v traditsionnoy kul’ture i fol’klore tsygan-kelderarov [Mosquito as the Mistress of Gold and the Hostess of Treasures in Traditional Culture of the Kalderash Gipsy]. Traditsionnaya kul’tura [Traditional culture]. 2012. No. 3. Pp. 120–128. In Russian.

Edemskiy M. B. (1908) Iz kokshen’gskikh predaniy [From Legends of Kokshen’ga]. Zhivaya starina [Alive antiquity]. 1908. Vol. 1–2. In Russian.

Fetish i tabu: Antropologiya deneg v Rossii (2013) [Fetish and Taboo: Anthropology of Money in Russia]. Comp. A. S. Arkhipov, Yu. Fruchtmann. Moscow. In Russian.

Grinchenko B. D. (1895) Etnograficheskie materialy, sobrannye v Chernigovskoy i sosednikh s ney guberniyakh [Ethnographic Materials Collected in Chernigiv and its Neighboring Provinces]. Vypusk 1. Rasskazy, skazki, predaniya, poslovitsy, zagadki i pr. [Issue 1. Stories, Tales, Legends, Proverbs, Riddles etc]. Chernigiv. In Russian and Ukrainian.

Grinchenko B. D. (1897) Etnograficheskie materialy, sobrannye v Chernigovskoy i sosednikh s ney guberniyakh [Ethnographic Materials Collected in Chernigiv and its Neighboring Provinces]. Vypusk 2.  Rasskazy, skazki, predaniya, poslovitsy, zagadki i pr. [Issue 2. Stories, Tales, Legends, Proverbs, Riddles etc]. Chernigiv. In Russian and Ukrainian.

Kotel’nikova N. E. (1990) Stabil’nye povestvovatel’nye komponenty v neskazochnoy proze o kladakh [Stable Narrative Components in Believe Folk Prose about the Treasure]. Russkiy fol’klor [Russian folklore]. St. Petersburg. T. 30. Pp. 215–229. In Russian.

Krinichnaya N. A. (1991) Predaniya Russkogo Severa [The Legends of the Russian North]. St. Petersburg. In Russian.


Narodnye russkie legendy A. N. Afanas’eva (1990) [Russian folk legends by A. N. Afanas’ev]. Novosibirsk. In Russian.

Novikov Yu. A. (comp.) (2005) Po zavetam stariny [According to Precepts from Antiquity]. Mifologicheskie skazaniya, zagovory, pover’ya, bytovaya magiya staroobryadtsev Litvy [Mythological Tales, Charms, Beliefs, Everyday Magic among Old Believers of Lithuania]. St. Petersburg. In Russian.

Novitskiy Ya. P. (1908) Zaporozhskie i gaydamatskie klady [Zaporizhzhya and Haidamak Treasures]. Alexandrovsk. In Russian.

Simonsuuri L. (1991) Ukazatel’ tipov i motivov finskikh mifologicheskikh rasskazov [The Type and Motif Index of Finnish Belief Legends and Memorates]. Translated with a preface by N. A. Pruszynskaya. Petrozavodsk. In Russian.

Sirovatka On, Šrávková M. (comp.) (1982) Devětkrát les, třikrát ves. Lidové pověsti z Hané [“Nine times to the forest, three times larger the weight”. Folk tales of Hané]. Ostrava. In Czech.

Skazki i pesni Belozerskogo kraya (1999) [Tales and Songs of Belozero Region] Collected by B.N. and Yu. N. Sokolov. In 2 vol. St. Petersburg. Vol.  1. In Russian.

Smirnov V. (1921) Klady, pany, razboyniki [Hoards, Lords, Robbers]. Trudy Kostromskogo nauchnogo obshchestva po izucheniyu mestnogo kraya [The Proceedings of Kostroma Scholarly Society for Studies of the Local Region]. Vol. XXVI. Kostroma. In Russian.

Vlasova M. N. (comp., ed.) (2001) Neizdannye materialy ekspeditsiy na Russkiy Sever 1926–1928 gg. [Unpublished Materials of Field Expeditions to the Russian North 1926–1928]. Skazki. Legendy. Bylichki. Detskiy fol’klor [Tales. Legends. Bylichkas the Memorates. Children’s Folklore]. St. Petersburg. In Russian.

Zheleznov I. I. (1910) Ural’tsy. Ocherki byta ural’skikh kazakov [The Ural Dwellers. Essays on the Everyday Life of the Ural Cossacks]. Complete Works of Ioasaph Ignatievich Zheleznov. Vol. 3. Ed. 3. St. Petersburg. In Russian.